Corn starch. A five-pound gummy bear. A yodeling pickle. This is the shelf for the wonderfully weird stuff — oddball finds requested by readers, plus anything else strange enough to earn a card. Every link below was verified against its exact Amazon listing.
Don't see your oddball below? Search it right here — every search carries the site's link, so anything you buy supports us at no extra cost to you.
Tip: buy within 24 hours of clicking and the site gets the credit.
How the shelf works. Got an oddball you want added here? Just tell Moxie what it is — he'll pass it along, and it'll get a proper card with a verified link. The weirder the request, the better the shelf gets.
16 oz box | gluten-free thickener
The one that started the whole shelf. A buddy needed corn starch, and that turned into the best idea on the site: a home for every oddball request. Twice the thickening power of flour, zero drama.
Check Price on Amazon →
5 lb cherry gummy | approx. 9.5 in tall
One thousand times the size of a regular gummy bear. A party centerpiece, a dare, a gift nobody forgets. Cherry, glorious, and five full pounds of it.
Check Price on Amazon →
30 assorted ducks | bath + party favors
Thirty rubber ducks. For Jeep ducking, party favors, bath time armadas, or just because. An oddball shelf classic.
Check Price on Amazon →
8 in | true left-handed grind
The 10% of the population the scissor industry forgot. Reversed blades, contoured handles, and no more hand cramps for the southpaws.
Check Price on Amazon →
12 × 3.75 oz cans | wild-caught brisling
Tiny Norwegian fish, hand-packed in good olive oil. The pantry oddball that turns into a personality trait.
Check Price on Amazon →
Musical novelty toy | push-button yodel
Press the button. It yodels. That's the whole product, and honestly, that's enough. The undisputed heavyweight champion of white-elephant gifts.
Check Price on Amazon →As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.